BREAKING UP IS HARD TO DO: A GUIDE FOR FRIENDS AND FAMILY

The immediate prompt for this brief article is the report on February 23, 2013 that Tiger Woods and his ex -wife Elin Nordegren were spotted at an event where they spoke together not for 30 seconds but 30 minutes.  In one sense this is not newsworthy at all but during the week, I had a spate of cases where I know the parents or friends and family of recently separated couples and where the parents/friends/family always knew that this marriage could not last and/or the couple never belonged together or he/she changed and is now unworthy of the friend or family member. This happens every day but when it happens to friends and family we want to rush to support the person we are closest to with words of support.

Express those views with caution or at your peril. Yes, you never did like his wife or her husband.  Yes, you saw all of the failings and frailties that your friend or loved one could not see; blinded by good looks or charm or in too many case: “none of the above”.  But when your friend finally screws up the courage to end the relationship or move in that direction, be aware that today, the rules are different.

Separation and divorce are never easy.  As folks who see this everyday, we recognize that a failed relationship is a difficult thing to face.  But in many cases, “history” or “children” or whatever mean that there is a wide gulf between separation and divorce. Friends and family who step into that breach with their views do so at their peril as couples often second guess themselves today and decide to reconcile.  If that occurs, your candor in expressing your views about the spouse is the only things that is left and sometimes that means loss of a friendship or relationship that you treasure.

If your friend or family member comes to confide in you that he or she needs to end their relationship with a spouse, be supportive.  But do so knowing that many marriages irretrievably broken on Monday are back together in some bizarre way by Thursday and that too much vocal support at your end could end up costing you an important friendship.

4 THINGS NOT TO PUT IN YOUR ONLINE DATING PROFILE DURING A DIVORCE

While reading a press release by the American Academy of Matrimonial Lawyers this afternoon, I realized individuals in the midst of a divorce regularly receive warnings about what is acceptable and safe to post on Facebook and what might get them in trouble. They also receive advice from their counsel about when it is appropriate to start dating again and when, for strategic reasons in a divorce or custody case, it might be best to wait. But what about when the two collide and people in the middle of a divorce put a profile on an online dating site? Here are five things I hope my clients never put on their online dating profiles:

1.             Pictures of your kids: While your children are undoubtedly adorable, your spouse (or ex-spouse) will have a field day in a custody case with the family photographs you put on your dating profile. Your decision to upload a picture of you with your child from last Christmas may have been completely innocent, but the other parent can easily turn it around on you, claiming you are using your children to find dates or exposing your children to internet predators.

 

2.             A claim you don’t have kids (when you do): The exact opposite of putting pictures of your children on your profile, if you have kids, don’t claim you are childless on your dating profile. Immediately, the other parent will claim you must not love your children if you won’t tell anyone about them.

 

3.             Anything about your income: If you are in the middle of litigating your income in a divorce or support case, and claiming in court that you make less than $50,000 a year, stating on your online dating profile that you make more than $200,000 per year might not be the wisest move. While it might attract people that otherwise wouldn’t respond to your profile, you will pay for it dearly in court.

 

4.             Stating you are divorced, or single (when you aren’t): Often times in a divorce or support matter, the date you separated from your spouse is very important. If you posted that you are single on your dating profile, weeks or months before you spouse knew your marriage was over, you may have set your date of separation unintentionally. You may have also admitted infidelity (or at least an attempt at infidelity) prior to your official date of separation, which may preclude you from collecting spousal support. To be safe, I wouldn’t put up a profile on a dating site at all until you are definitely separated. 

LONG TERM SEPARATION: THE "UNDIVORCED"

The New York Times ran an interesting article on long term separations – or the “un-divorced” as the writer, Pamela Paul calls it – as an alternative to divorces. It raises some interesting points about the benefits – and the complications – of a long term separation. In a state such as Pennsylvania, where separation can be grounds for seeking spousal support and child support, long-term separation may have both strategic and practical benefits to a dependent spouse by potentially providing years of support.

Additional benefits also may include the continuation of medical and tax benefits. For some cases, medical coverage is a critical aspect due to a major medical condition or insufficient income to obtain independent insurance coverage, while most people benefit from filing their taxes jointly.

Issues to consider, particularly in Pennsylvania where there is no “legal separation” per se, is that being separated has no legal effect on things like Social Security, insurance benefits, estate benefits, or retirement benefits. Some retirement plans designate the spouse as the beneficiary of the plan, therefore, if the spouse dies during the period of separation, the benefits pass to the other spouse as if the separation never occurred. In Pennsylvania, until a grounds order is entered, you are married and death benefits, property rights, etc. will pass to the surviving spouse by operation of law.

Long-term separation is often a convenient arrangement, rather than a desired situation. In many cases, it forestalls the inevitable divorce, but on the other hand, it may just be a way to deal with a marriage that he ceased to work in a traditional sense, but that those involved find too much invested to sever the legal ties to one another. Like all things, there is no cookie-cutter approach to long-term separation; each situation requires careful consideration of the benefits and risks (ex. Joint taxes maximizes tax benefits, but also can exposure each party to liability for what is disclosed in the return). Finding the balance between an unhappy happy and a tolerable (if not happy) separation is not easy, but it could the best solution for some people.

SOME FREE ADVICE ABOUT MARRIAGE COUNSELING

Every once in a while, a good deed does not go unpunished.  About a month ago I received a call from an acquaintance with whom I worked performing community work several years ago.  Could she stop in and chat?  As one might expect, people do not just stop in to “chat” with divorce lawyers without some particular thoughts in mind.

We met for about 20 minutes.  By the standards of our parents’ generation she had the perfect marriage.  Beautiful kids, financial security and prominence in the community.  But as is so often the case things were not feeling that way. There was a suggestion that perhaps her spouse had not been faithful and, being an intelligent woman, her response was to research.  The results were not encouraging.  Because we knew each other, I got what I call the “ultimate question”.  Was it time to end it? Personally, I hate this question.  I have been doing this line of work for almost thirty years; I have been married twice during that time.  But, who am I to tell another person whether he or she should try to preserve a relationship that was once seen as a lifetime commitment?  There are days when I hear stories that make me want to blurt out: “You must be kidding.”  But that’s not a lawyer’s role.  Lawyers are at their best when they are Socratic.  Ask the questions.  Explore the options.  Then let the client make the decision.

The subsidiary question I had posed in this meeting was whether marriage counseling made sense.  Having once done it, I am not a big fan of marriage counseling.  It is my own belief that when confronted in meetings by people we don’t know, our first goal is to try to look like reasonable people and to impress our new found acquaintance, the marriage counselor. Of course this comes at a price and that price is called ‘candor’. Second, there is a tendency to pull punches.  I wish I could recall how many times a client has lit up in appreciation when I observed that it sounded like a spouse was more committed to a job or the children than the marriage.  A recent article about how couples fight about money noted that many fights over money are merely stalking horses for other issues.  I can’t look you in the face and tell you that I am unhappy about your weight, your lethargy, your inability to discipline our child, your fawning admiration of the idiot neighbor.  But I can easily summon the courage to tell you that you should mow your own lawn or cut back on the credit cards.

So, I find that marriage counseling tends to work best as a second step.  Step one is to see a counselor individually and do the preliminary work.  With your own counselors you and your spouse can each let loose not only about each other but about what is working or not working in your own life besides your marriage. You can say what you want and not fear immediate rebuttal, rejection or impeachment.  You can hopefully sort out where life has brought you and, most important; where you want to go next.  That next step may mean separation and divorce.  That’s alright too.  But many times, individual therapy causes the patient to gain perspective.  Also, don’t kid yourself.  In individual therapy it’s easy to throw the punch and, as Napoleon once suggested, blame everyone not in the room.  A good therapist is going to spar with you; challenging your views and asking questions intended to make you think.

Once you have put some time into getting your own emotional house in order; it is time to take the show on the road and do some couples counseling.  But if your individual counseling convinces you that you are absolutely destined to end your current relationship; then don’t dishonestly go into marriage counseling.  Ask your spouse for permission to speak to her therapist.  Lay your thinking on the line.  If nothing else this will help your spouse get insight from her own therapist as to how you got to your conclusion.  That’s healthy for both of you.

I’m also a big fan of the written word.  Not the texted or instant messaged thought.  I mean something you will put hours into just as you did a paper in college.  Your marriage is a relationship in which both you and your spouse have made an enormous investment.  Don’t sell out cheap.

Divorce is often made more expensive because the lawyers are carrying their clients heavy emotional baggage. Carry your own.  You will not find it pleasant but you will ultimately feel better about the experience.  And you will save a stack of money.

"IS IT TRUE THAT I WILL BE DIVORCED 90 DAYS AFTER I FILE?" and "WHAT'S A LEGAL SEPARATION?"

Ask any divorce lawyer in Pennsylvania to specify the two most common questions he or she might encounter in an initial interview and the answer will inevitably include one or both of the questions recited in the title.

The second question is easy to answer. It is pretty safe to say that it is impossible to be divorced in the first ninety days after a divorce is filed.  The law is clear. For the first ninety days after a divorce complaint is served (and service must come after the complaint is filed) neither party is eligible to consent to divorce. And for a divorce to move forward it is pretty much necessary for both sides to file affidavits of consent.  Complicating matters is the common fact that many people who file for divorce will for strategic reasons refuse to consent to the same divorce.  Absent the consent of both parties a divorce can move forward based upon either fault based grounds (adultery, cruelty, an ambiguous term called indignities and some other obscure grounds) or a legal separation of two of more years. Only after divorce grounds are established can a divorce be granted.  And in almost all situations the divorce will not come until claims for distribution of property and alimony are resolved by the parties or decided finally by a court. So there is no divorce after 90 days unless the parties are cooperating and there is no divorce even after a two year separation unless the economic issues are resolved. It makes the process slow and expensive but the lawmakers in the General Assembly have passed laws that favor delay in the hope that it may prompt reconciliation.

We have noted that a divorce can proceed even without consent where there has been a separation of two or more years. The question of when a couple is separated for purposes of the Divorce Code is one of the most difficult to answer.  In 2005 the legislature helped to clarify the separation by declaring that there was a rebuttable presumption that a couple was separated when a divorce action was filed. But the presumption is rebuttable where one party can show that there has not been a complete cessation of cohabitation.

An end to cohabitation does not require a separate household. The law as it has evolved in the courts that cohabitation ends when the parties show a clear intention to no longer be together.

Twelve Things To Consider Before Filing for Divorce

My fellow blogger, Al Nye, the author of Maine Divorce Law Blog, recently sent me the following article.  Its a nice primer relating to things to think about as a client in making the decision whether or not to separate and divorce. 

Al writes the following:

You know the numbers.  It's projected right now that about half of all new marriages end up in divorce.  It's a horrible statistic that doesn't begin to suggest the emotional and financial strain that it puts on families.  Other than the death of your spouse, divorce is probably the most stressful event you'll ever face.  I've had women discussing their divorce in my office become violently ill.  I've seen hardened fishermen cry in open court during their divorce hearing.  Make no mistake – divorce is hell.

 

So what have I learned after being a lawyer for nearly 30 years and helping many folks go through this difficult process?  If you believe that a divorce is in your future, here are 12 things think about:

1.                   Don't do it.  If you feel there is any chance that you can save your marriage, try it.  See a marriage counselor, talk to a therapist, seek spiritual help, eat some humble pie – whatever, but don't take the step of filing for a divorce lightly.  In all my years as a lawyer, I've never seen a divorce that wasn't emotionally grueling on the parties and their children.  If there is any chance at all of saving your marriage, give it a shot – even if it doesn't work, you'll feel better later on knowing that you tried everything possible.

2.                   Get a lawyer.  In most states, divorces involve lots of paperwork and a dizzying array of legal decisions.  You need to know your legal rights and responsibilities and should talk to an attorney BEFORE you are ready to begin proceedings.  Be wary of books giving you legal advice.  Divorce laws vary greatly in the United States and you need to speak with a lawyer familiar with the laws in the state where you live.

3.                   Kids First.  If you have children, it's never too early in the divorce proceeding to consider their needs.  How and when are you going to tell them about your decision to file for divorce?  Will you tell them yourself, or with your spouse?  It's important to make sure that they are told in such a way that it is clear to them that they are not the cause of the divorce, that they are still loved by both of you and that they'll still be taken care of.  Children suffer the most during a divorce so it's important that their routines be changed as little as possible.  Get or keep involved in their everyday activities.  Don't say anything negative about your spouse in front of them.  Don't take out the anger and frustration you may feel toward your spouse out on your children.  Make them your top priority.  Give your children all the love, attention, emotional and financial support you can during this stressful time. 

4.                   Copy Important Financial Documents.  Anything that has to do with your finances should be copied: 

·                                             Federal and state tax returns;

·                                             Recent Pay Stubs;

·                                             Bank and credit card statements;

·                                             Deeds and real estate appraisals;

·                                             Mortgage documents and statements;

·                                             Investment and retirement statements;

·                                             Wills and life insurance policies; and

·                                             Automobile titles.

Don't forget to check your home computer for some of this information.  If you use financial software like Quicken or some other program, back up a copy of your entire on-line file and save it to a CD.  Note that this is only a partial list of documents – your lawyer may want even more information.  Again, this should be done BEFORE you file for a divorce.  It's amazing how these documents seem to "disappear" once you file for your divorce.

5.                   Find out what you own.  Take stock of your possessions.    Get out a pencil and paper and write down everything that you own – you may not want to count every spice in the cupboard, but write down major items like automobiles, appliances, jewelry, furniture, antiques or anything else that is valuable.  You may want to omit all items under, say, $100 and list the remaining items.  You might also consider taking a video of the interior of the house and noting some of the more expensive possessions.  Pictures – say with a camera phone – also work well.

6.                   Find out what you owe.  The importance of getting a clear picture about your income and expenses can't be emphasized enough.  To a large extent, divorces are about money.  You say all you care about are the children?  Well, you need money to support them.  You want to stay in the marital home?  Do you have the ability to pay the mortgage?  Many times only one spouse is directly involved in the day-to-day payment of expenses.  If you're that spouse, you probably have a good handle on the debts and expenses of your family.  If you're not that spouse, you need to get up to speed in a hurry.  Either way, it's time for you to develop a household budget and know exactly where all the money is going.  If possible, take a look at your Quicken report or your bank statements or checking account register and determine where you're spending your money and what your debts are at this time.  Keep in mind that many people spend quite a bit of cash each week – so you need to factor that into your budget.  Knowing your budget and expenses is extremely important in the beginning of the case when spousal support, child support or both might be an issue.  It's also crucial later on when you're discussing settlement or going to trial.  Once you're living on your own again, you need to know this information to intelligently assess your needs.

7.                   Determine your spouse's income.  My experience is that many husbands and wives don't really know what their spouses make for money.  If your spouse has a regular salary, get copies of his or her W2's and pay stubs.  In addition to their regular income, do they receive bonuses, tips or other fringe benefits – like reimbursements for car or housing expenses, employer paid insurance benefits or free meals?  Who pays for health insurance and are there any employer contributions?  Take into account employment sponsored retirement accounts, IRAs, 401(k)s or annuities.  If your spouse is self-employed, owns a business or ever gets paid in cash, it's often difficult to accurately determine income.  Get as much information as possible and present it to your lawyer for review.  You may need the help of an accountant or other expert to help in this area.

8.                   Figure out what happens when you move out.  Someone generally leaves the marital home to find another place to live.  Once again, BEFORE you decide whether or not to leave, talk to a lawyer.  It can have adverse consequences to be the one to leave the marital home and some lawyers routinely advise clients to stay in the marital residence if at all possible (absent abuse).  Depending on your state laws, being the one to move out could weaken your position later as it relates to child custody or your ability to ever return to your home.  Once someone does leave, you need to figure out how to pay the family debt.  You and your spouse are going to have to allocate your debts – if you can't agree on how, the court will do it for you.  If you're still paying on debt that you brought into the marriage, this may be considered "non-marital debt" and be your responsibility in addition to the other debt. 

9.                   Divide up bank accounts.  It's best if you do this with your spouse or at least after notifying your spouse.  But if you fear that your spouse is going to immediately empty out all your joint bank accounts upon being told about the divorce, consider withdrawing half – but not all – of the money you have in your savings accounts.  If you can withdraw half of the money from the checking account without causing a financial mess, you may want to do that too.  Put the funds in a separate account in a different bank and don't spend them if at all possible!  You'll undoubtedly have to divulge what you did with the money so keep track of it.  As usual, check with your lawyer before taking this step.

10.               Know what you can earn.  Living in two households is always more expensive than living in one.  Whatever you make, it won't seem to be enough.  If you earn a regular salary, is there a way for you to work overtime to supplement your income?  Do you have any other way to legitimately earn more?  If you've been out of the workforce for a while, what type of income can you realistically expect when returning?  Do you need extensive training or more education before you return to work?  Is your earning limited because you have small children and can only work part time?  If you work full time, will that significantly increase your child care expenses?  If your job requires extensive travel, will you continue to be able to do it and still see the children on a regular basis?

11.               Take a look at your credit history.  Do you and your spouse have credit cards in your own individual names?  If not, you may want to apply for them now to establish your own credit history.  If your credit is poor, take steps now to improve it.  Unfortunately, my experience is that money in a divorce often becomes so tight that bills get overlooked or not paid on time and the credit rating of both spouses suffers.  If at all possible, try to not let this happen.  You also need to consider canceling credit cards if one spouse routinely runs up huge credit card bills.  Another alternative is to reduce the spending limit.  Be sure to talk to your lawyer about this as well as your spouse.

12.               Save, save, save.  This is advice that you should do long before you even consider getting a divorce.  Save as much money as you can in your own name so that you have easy access to cash in the event you need it.  If your spouse is the primary breadwinner and moves out and refuses to pay the bills, you need to pay them until a court issues a temporary order indicating who is responsible for payment.  Many times, even when filing an expedited request for a hearing, it takes weeks or even months to get into court on a temporary support request. If you're the person moving out, you'll need money for a security deposit on an apartment or to buy appliances and other household items.  Start saving now to ease the financial burden that nearly all couples go through when obtaining a divorce. Finally, don't forget the major expense that you and your spouse will both have when getting a divorce: legal retainers.